Here is something I tell people all the time: just because you are shacking up together does not mean you are married. Living under the same roof, sharing bills, even raising kids together — none of that, by itself, makes you spouses in the eyes of the law.
But Colorado is one of the few states that still recognizes common law marriage, and that fact catches a lot of people off guard. Some rely on it as a kind of insurance plan, assuming they are “basically married” and protected accordingly. Others discover, usually at the worst possible moment, that a partner’s family is claiming their late loved one was common law married, with everything that follows for property and inheritance. Either way, the reality is more complicated than most people assume.
What Common Law Marriage Is — and Isn’t
A common law marriage is a real, legally valid marriage. It simply skips the license and the ceremony. In Colorado, there are two ways to become legally married: formally, by getting a license and solemnizing the marriage, or informally, through a common law marriage. Once established, a common law marriage carries the same legal weight as any other — the same rights, the same obligations, and the same need for a formal divorce to end it.
What it is not is automatic. Cohabitation alone does not create a marriage. Neither does a long relationship, shared finances, or having children together. Those facts can be evidence of a marriage, but they are not the marriage itself.
Colorado Is One of the Few States That Still Recognizes It
Most states have done away with common law marriage. Colorado is in the minority that has kept it, one of only about ten jurisdictions where you can still form one. In my view, that is not a good thing. The doctrine is a relic of the frontier era, back when officiants and courthouses were scarce and couples on the Wild West had no practical way to formalize a marriage. Those conditions are long gone. Today the doctrine serves very little useful purpose and mostly creates confusion.
How a Court Decides Whether You’re Common Law Married
This is where the false-insurance problem really bites. People assume they qualify without understanding what it actually takes to prove a common law marriage — and proving it is harder than they think.
The leading case for decades was People v. Lucero, decided in 1987. The Colorado Supreme Court refined that standard in 2021 in Hogsett v. Neale, which now controls. Under Hogsett, a common law marriage requires two core things:
• A mutual agreement to be married. Both parties must actually intend to enter the legal and social institution of marriage — to share a life together as spouses in a committed, intimate relationship of mutual support and obligation. One person’s hope or assumption is not enough; the intent has to be mutual.
• Conduct that manifests that agreement. An agreement alone does not do it. There must be evidence — how the couple actually lived — showing they held themselves out as married.
Courts look at the totality of the circumstances, and no single factor decides the question. The kinds of conduct that can show intent to be married include:
• Living together as a couple
• Reputation in the community as spouses — in other words, holding yourselves out to the public as married
• Joint bank and credit accounts
• Jointly owned property
• Joint tax returns
• Use of a shared surname by one spouse or by the children
There is also a threshold requirement worth knowing. For any common law marriage entered on or after September 1, 2006, both parties must have been at least eighteen years old, and the marriage cannot otherwise be prohibited. See C.R.S. § 14-2-109.5.
Why It’s a False Insurance Plan
Here is the trap. Because no license or ceremony is required, people convince themselves they are common law married and stop worrying about it. They treat it as a safety net. But whether a common law marriage actually exists is a fact-intensive question that no one can answer for certain in advance — it depends on evidence, credibility, and a judge’s weighing of the whole picture.
That uncertainty cuts both ways. Someone who believes they are married may find they cannot prove it when it matters — at a separation, or when a partner dies. And on the flip side, someone who never intended to marry can find themselves defending against a claim brought by a former partner or a deceased partner’s family. The doctrine that feels like protection is really just a question mark.
The Bottom Line
If you want the legal protections of marriage, get married — or put your intentions in writing. If you want to avoid an unintended marriage, understand that how you live and hold yourselves out can matter. And if someone tells you not to worry because you are “common law married,” take it with a grain of salt.
I put it to clients this way: you’re not common law married until a court of law says you are. Because these questions turn entirely on the specific facts, it is worth talking to an experienced Colorado family law attorney before you rely on — or dispute — a common law marriage.
And if you want certainty instead of a future courtroom debate, get a marriage license and put the marriage on the record.
This website is not intended to constitute legal advice or the provision of legal services. By posting and/or maintaining this website and its contents, Searcy Friedman Law does not intend to solicit legal business from clients located in states or jurisdictions where Searcy Friedman Law or its individual attorneys are not licensed or authorized to practice law.
Searcy Friedman Law © 2025-2026. All rights reserved.
